“In This Way”: An Extended Review of Kingdom Through Covenant

October 1, 2012 — 2 Comments


Earlier this year, Crossway released a bombshell named Kingdom Through Covenant into the playing field of evangelical theological studies. That may be a slight exaggeration, but considering that the Gospel Coalition gathered Darrell Bock (a progressive dispensationalist), Michael Horton (the leading mainstream covenant theologian guru), and Douglas Moo (perhaps a via media between the two) in order to review it, it is a book that is definitely making waves.

Co-authors Peter Gentry and Stephen Wellum offered their own response to the 3 reviews, and if you’re paying attention to the blue text, you can click on thru and wade through the discussion yourself. Since I’ve got a review copy thanks to Crossway, I’ll be offering my own thoughts. To that, I thought I’d chart a different course in reviewing the book and incorporate some of the authors’ own theological method into my analysis. There are plenty of straightforward reviews, so I think there is room for creativity on my part.


Gentry is an Old Testament scholar, while Wellum is more of a systematics guy. Because of that, rather than collaborating the whole book through, Wellum authored the opening 3 chapters setting the theological and hermeneutical context. Then, Gentry authored the extensive middle section that covers all the covenants in deep exegetical detail. Finally, Wellum authored the final two chapters that summarize the whole argument for the middle path between dispensationalism and covenant theology.

Review by Quote

What I noticed as I was reading the opening chapters though is that Wellum is extremely fond of summarizing his points with the introductory marker “In this way.” Gentry, in his sections is extremely fond of studying linguistic usage in order to establish the meaning of a text. So, I thought I’d use Gentry’s approach on Wellum’s chapters to give you a list of quotes that capture the gist of Kingdom Through Covenant. Rather than offering a normal review, I thought I’d work through it by quotes.

A “Via Media”

In this way, I thought I could offer more material and direct quotation from a book than a typical review. But in doing that, I’ll offer less analysis of the books contents from a critical point of view. Part of that is because I don’t have a firm enough position myself. I went to “Dispensational U” yet wasn’t entirely convinced and don’t consider myself a dispensationalist (except in maybe an ultra, ultra progressive sense). On the other hand, though I now live within walking distance of Reformed Theological Seminary, I still haven’t converted to full on covenant theology and so don’t quite fit there either. In large part, that’s why I was excited to see Kingdom Through Covenant released and after I’m done really working my way through it may not have much criticism to offer. We’ll see.

Table of Contents

As I fill in quotes, I’ll keep a running list going on here:

In the meantime, keep an eye for upcoming posts and you’ll find out how “in this way” Kingdom Through Covenant charts the middle road between dispensationalism and covenant theology!

Book Details

[You’re reading this collection of quotes from Kingdom Through Covenant because I asked Crossway for a review copy and they said yes!]


Posts Twitter Facebook

I'm an avid reader, musician, and high school Bible teacher living in central Florida. I have many paperback books and our house smells of rich glade air freshners. If you want to know more, then let's connect!

2 responses to “In This Way”: An Extended Review of Kingdom Through Covenant

  1. I’m looking forward to seeing your review and especially because you’re approaching it differently. Also the fact that you’re not ready to fully associate with dispensationalism nor covenantalism (like myself) makes me wonder how you’ll feel about this book. I bought it but unfortunately will probably only find time to read and review it once a lot of the discussion has settled down!

    • So far I’ve liked it, but I’m trying to see what kind of criticisms it gets from both sides before fully making up my mind. It’s a bear to read, so it may take a while for you to find the time to dig in yourself!

Want To Add Your Thoughts?